Is hiring a Real Estate Agent worth the commission
The short answer
Yes, a good agent is worth the commission. A bad one isn't, and most articles won't tell you that.
I've been a certified residential appraiser for more than 20 years, and I'm also a REALTOR® with Jack Conway. That means I've sat on both sides of the table: valuing homes for lenders and selling them for clients. Here's what that taught me. Sellers rarely lose money on the commission itself. They lose it on a wrong price, a bad measurement, weak exposure, or a deal that falls apart between contract and closing. A good agent prevents those problems. A bad one creates them.
What the commission actually pays for
Most of the work happens where you can't see it. When you list with an agent, you're paying for:
- Exposure. Your home gets in front of buyers across all the major platforms, not just a yard sign and a post on social media.
- Buyer vetting. A serious buyer and a curious one look the same at an open house. Your agent screens them, and checks that the buyer's financing is real before you take a home off the market.
- Open houses and showings. Your agent runs them, so you aren't opening your door to strangers yourself.
- Deal management. Your agent meets the inspector, coordinates the appraiser, and stays in contact with the lender. When the inspection report comes back with surprises, someone has to negotiate it.
The tasks are boring, and they're also where deals get saved or lost.
What an appraiser sees that most agents miss
This is where my appraiser background matters most. The lender's appraiser has to follow strict rules for measuring and valuing a home. If your agent prices off a number that doesn't follow those rules, your price won't survive the appraisal.
Two mistakes I see over and over:
- Counting a finished basement as living area. Appraisers do not include below-grade space in gross living area. Comps that include the lower level will come out too high.
- Counting space that isn't living area. Porches, sunrooms, and other unheated spaces don't count either.
A real example. I appraised a home where the listing broker had counted an unheated sunporch as living area. That made the home about 300 square feet larger on paper. His comparable sales were chosen to match that bigger number. Mine were based on the true living area, which meant smaller homes and lower prices. The gap between his number and mine almost cost the deal.
.
Why the wrong agent costs more than the right one
Not every agent is worth hiring, and I'll say so plainly. One of my clients came to me after working with a broker who barely communicated. The broker listed the home well above where it should have been priced, and the client was left in the dark about what was happening. The client lost trust, refused to keep working with that brokerage, and hired me instead.
Two things went wrong, and both are fixable:
- Pricing. An overpriced listing sits, and a home that sits starts to look like something is wrong with it. The seller ends up chasing the market down, usually after losing the best weeks of buyer attention.
- Communication. A seller should never have to wonder what's happening with their home. If your agent goes quiet, that's a warning sign.
That's why the question isn't "what does an agent cost?" It's "what does a mistake cost?"
What the numbers say
The National Association of REALTORS®' 2025 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers found that homes sold by the owner went for a median of $360,000, compared with $425,000 for homes sold with an agent. That's about an 18% difference. Only 5% of sales were by owner, a record low, while 91% of sellers used an agent (NAR).
A fair caveat: the homes in those two groups aren't identical, so the gap isn't a guarantee for your house. But the reasons behind it are worth knowing. Owners selling on their own said the hardest parts were pricing the home, getting it ready, and selling within their timeframe. And 40% of them didn't actively market the home at all.
Those are the exact jobs you hire an agent to do.
How to tell if an agent is worth it
Before you sign a listing agreement, ask these questions:
- How did you arrive at this price? You want comparable sales and a clear explanation, not a number that sounds good.
- How do you measure living area, and which comps do you use? An agent who can't answer this clearly is a risk at appraisal time.
- How will you market my home, and where? Ask for specifics, not "all the usual places."
- How often will I hear from you, and how? Get it in plain terms before you hire anyone.
- Have you handled a situation like mine? Estates, probate, divorce, foreclosure, and renovation loans like the FHA 203k all have traps a first-timer won't see coming.
If you get vague answers, keep interviewing.
The bottom line
So, is hiring a real estate agent worth the commission? When the agent protects your price, manages your deal, and keeps you informed, yes. When they don't, no.
I'm a certified appraiser and a REALTOR®, so I can tell you whether an offer will hold up at appraisal before it ever reaches the bank. If you're thinking of selling and want an honest read on what your home is worth, reach out to me for a conversation.
Source: NAR, FSBOs Reach All-Time Low as More Sellers Rely on Agents, based on the 2025 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers.
